On Debating

We have just started on debating as the latest part of our English curriculum. We are formed into groups and assigned topics to debate on. All this is fine. Here's the part which I do not like nor understand about debating. We are told whether to support the topic or oppose the topic. Why are we told whether to support or to oppose? First of all, I never actually get to sincerely and honestly mull over the topic in my head and come to a decision. I just have to accept it that I am supporting this or opposing this. Perhaps, by some luck, if the side of contention which we are directed to coincides with my personal opinion, I will be able to put my sincere arguments on the motion. Otherwise, I would have to brainstorm, create seemingly convincing arguments for my side, or do research on what other people say or argue that is in favor of our side of the argument.

While I agree that every motion, proposal or decision will have multiple faces, each one of us would have our own personal opinion on this motion unless we have yet to come to a decision or are sitting on the fence. However, when the arguments we present in a debate is not a true reflection of our stand or our point of view, then the debate is no longer a platform for honest discussion, in which there is a certain desired outcome such as a search for some sort of truth or beneficial solution or an understanding of understanding of an issue from certain angles and what is it that we are concerned about. In this situation the result of debate will depend on the debating quality of an individual than to the motion.

The danger of this is that a creator of good arguments will able to swing the motion in the any direction. It is also true that the event the most righteous side also need the argument. Arguments, which are crystal clear and convincing. So if the idea of this exercise is to train individuals to create and deliver convincing argument by their fast and critical thinking then I am fine with this. But if it just for creating arguments without any belief on the motion, I have my reservations.